We Always Come Back
Posted by Nicole Wiesner on 1/07/2009
I’ve spent my life loving addicts. I’ve hopelessly and helplessly yearned for love from alcoholics, potheads, crack addicts, people addicted to morphine, uppers, downers, cigarettes, coffee, aspirin, other women, the list goes on and on. You name the addiction and I’ve probably tried to be the one to make a difference in their life. So, it’s no surprise that I’ve struggled with addiction myself. I’ve even been proud of the fact that my addictions are relatively harmless compared to most. And so the cycle continues.
I’ve loved a couple of recovering or recovered addicts as well. My grandfather struggled with alcohol and drug addiction upon returning from WWII. When my mother fell ill as a child, he turned to religion for help and managed to quit drinking, smoking and doing drugs. What I learned from him, and a lesson I seem destined to learn over and over again, is that even if the addict isn’t practicing their addiction, that doesn’t necessarily mean that they won’t exhibit addict behavior. My grandfather continued to struggle with his anger, his abusiveness, his tremendous sadness. If you don’t deal with the underlying reasons for your addiction, it’s almost impossible to live a fulfilling life, with or without the substances.
I was surprised to learn that one of the post show topics for Dublin Carol was whether or not Mary came back at 5:00 to collect her father. I was told the audience was usually split down the middle on this issue. Everyone’s experiences are different, of course, but as someone with a history of loving addicts (familial and otherwise) I have to say: we always come back.
In fact, a lot of you grabbed me after the show to say “well, I’m an optimist. I think she comes back. This confrontation between them HAS to result in a better relationship.” I never knew how to respond. On the surface, and for Mary, I hoped that was true. But I’m just not sure that IS the optimistic view. Experience tells me that a reconnection with him will result in years of new hurts: his silence, his continuing struggles with addiction, his preference of his son, his unavailability, his selfishness, his deep sadness, his feelings of inadequacy, his inability to be held accountable for his actions.
But I do think Mary returned. And maybe that means I’m a pessimist. I think we always return. Some of us become addicted to loving people who are unavailable.
My experience working on this play was remarkable. I will be forever grateful to the Steppenwolf, its artistic and technical staff, the incomparable Amy Morton, and my fabulous cohorts Billy and Stephen for all of the love and hard work that went into bringing this play to you. It was an important topic for me. And its always terribly hard to say good-bye.
January 9th, 2009 at 11:27 am
Love your comments! Yes, you know addictive behavior and your role as Mary was completely right. Mary returns, and it is that tiny flame of the optimist that makes her return. It’s always there.
I do have a question–do you see this as a religious (Christmas) play or could it occur on any day/time? Several people in the after play discussion really wanted to make it a “return to Jesus” type of play. (one comment–”John put the tree in the center of the table–his life, he was turning around.”) I didn’t–what do you think?
I am one who read the original ending of the play and actually liked it better than having John sit and wait for Mary.
January 12th, 2009 at 10:03 am
Hi Gloria. Thank you for your comment. I’m not sure how to answer your question except to say that religion really didn’t have any bearing on the work I did for the play, nor did I contemplate it as a major theme. Conor or Amy or Billy might have more to say about that. But I’m also not sure that this could have taken place on any other day. It seems to me that if you live in the Western World this holiday season can conjure up strong feelings about family, regardless of whether or not you practice religion. If it weren’t Christmas Eve, and if Noel weren’t in the hospital leaving John completely alone, would John have even managed to let her in?